The Daily Pulse

General

Bilkis Bano Leaves Home State Following Supreme Court Bail for Two Convicts

Reported by Ishita Mukherjee (Staff Writer) · Hindustan Times - India ·

Verified — Confirmed by a second source: Indian Express - India

Confirmed by a second source: Indian Express - India

Important
Bilkis Bano Leaves Home State Following Supreme Court Bail for Two ConvictsPhoto: Wikimedia Commons

Bilkis Bano and her relatives departed from Gujarat in the early days of November, shortly after the Supreme Court permitted bail for a pair of individuals found guilty in her case. Her uncle, Abdul Razaq Mansuri, stated that the household moved away around November second or third, following the judicial decision. Mansuri mentioned that she had previously resided in a neighborhood within Devgadh Baria town before shifting elsewhere in the region, but has now crossed state borders.

The Legal Ruling

On October 28, justices MM Sundresh and PB Varale paused the life imprisonment terms of Bipinchand Kanaiyalal Joshi, also referenced as Lala Doctor, and Pradip Ramanlal Modhiya. The bench pointed to their seventeen-year imprisonment term, while the Indian Express noted that one of the appellants also carries a severe physical handicap. This development occurred roughly twenty-four months after the apex court cancelled a state government choice from August 2022 that had freed all eleven imprisoned men. During the October hearing, the state administration itself objected to releasing the two individuals.

Survivor Reaction

Through her legal counsel, Senior Advocate Shobha Gupta, Bano released a public statement expressing profound shock and grief at learning about the ruling through media reports without receiving any prior notice or a chance to present her perspective. She described how old trauma returned, leaving her fearful for her household and children. She vowed to challenge the verdict for the sake of her offspring and three-year-old Saleha, who lost her life during the 2002 violence, adding that no survivor should have to fight an endless battle for equality.

Context

This development forms part of a long-running legal battle stemming from the 2002 Gujarat riots, where victims and survivors frequently navigate decades of court proceedings to secure accountability. High-profile criminal trials involving multiple appeals often see courts weigh long periods already spent in prison against the gravity of offenses when considering temporary relief like bail.

ExplainerWhy this matters

What Happened

The Supreme Court suspended the life sentences of two men convicted in the 2002 Gujarat riots case, granting them bail after they spent over seventeen years in prison. This followed an earlier 2024 ruling where the court canceled an earlier remission granted by the Gujarat government.

Why It Matters

This case is a landmark legal battle in India concerning justice for riot survivors, accountability for heinous crimes, and the proper legal jurisdiction between states when trials are transferred for fairness. The decision to grant bail after seventeen years brings up complex questions about prisoner rights versus the severe nature of the original crimes and the procedural rights of survivors to be heard.

What Happens Next

Bilkis Bano has declared her intention to legally challenge the bail order, meaning the matter will likely see further hearings in the Supreme Court as her legal team contests the suspension of sentences.

Read more at Hindustan Times - India →