General
State Court Directs Alternative Job for Man Disabled During Official Delay
Reported by Faizan Khan (Staff Writer) · The Hindu - National ·
The High Court of Karnataka ordered the state administration to evaluate a desk job for a 28-year-old job seeker who lost his right leg in a crash while waiting for his selection order. A bench consisting of Justice M. Nagaprasanna and Justice Hema Kulkarni granted relief to Shivakumar Hiremath from Bagalkot district. The judges canceled a previous June 2026 ruling by the Karnataka State Administrative Tribunal that had denied his plea for a different posting.
Job Process Delay
Mr. Hiremath took part in the 2019 drive to recruit civil police constables in Bengaluru city. He held a three-year diploma that counted as equal to a pre-university course for hiring rules. His name made the final list, but officials held back his appointment letter due to arguments over diploma equivalence. He and others went to the tribunal, which ruled in their favor on September 21, 2023, and told authorities to give out appointment letters within four months.
Accident and Denial
The authorities did not follow the deadline, leading the candidates to file contempt cases in 2024. The Police Department finally gave Mr. Hiremath an order on January 1, 2025, telling him to report on January 9. Before that happened, on November 30, 2024, he suffered a severe road accident while heading to Raichur, resulting in his right leg being cut off. Once told about his disability, the department turned down his request for a desk job.
Court Remarks
The judges called the case an extreme example of bureaucratic delay harming a candidate. The bench pointed out that the young man faced two blows, with bad luck taking his limb and official delay costing him his public service career. The court stated that the state must look at roles like second division assistant, assistant writer, junior data entry operator, or a similar administrative job that fits his education and physical state, rather than letting him carry the full weight of official sluggishness.
Context
Administrative delays in public sector hiring can sometimes lead to prolonged legal disputes when unexpected life events occur during the waiting period. Courts occasionally step in with unique remedies when rigid rules fail to account for official inaction.
ExplainerWhy this matters
What Happened
A job candidate won a court battle over recruitment rules but missed out on his police constable posting because officials delayed his appointment letter beyond the court-mandated deadline. During this extra wait time, he lost his leg in a road accident, and the department then rejected him because he no longer met physical fitness standards.
Why It Matters
This case highlights the legal responsibilities of public institutions when administrative delays directly harm a citizen's livelihood. It tests whether government bodies can hide behind strict physical criteria when their own failure to act on time caused the applicant to miss the window for joining service.
What Happens Next
The state government must now review the petitioner's qualifications and physical capacity to decide which administrative desk job or equivalent post can be offered to him in place of the constable position he originally cleared.
More in General
GeneralSource: The HinduWorth knowing
Cockroach Janta Party leaders appear before Special Executive Magistrate in Delhi
Reported by Abhishek Tiwari (Copy Editor) · The Hindu - National ·

