The Daily Pulse

General

India Rejects UN Call for Global Death‑Penalty Moratorium, Cites Sovereign Decision and Judicial Safeguards

Reported by Pooja Nair (Section Editor) · The Hindu - National ·

Source: The Hindu
Worth knowing
GeneralIndia Rejects UN Call for Global Death‑Penalty Moratorium, Cites Sovereign Decision and Judicial Safeguards
Representative image · Wikimedia Commons

What Happened

India voted against a United Nations proposal for a worldwide moratorium on the death penalty, arguing that the issue is a sovereign decision and that existing judicial safeguards – the “rarest of rare” rule and a High Court seal on sentences handed down by Sessions courts – justify keeping capital punishment.

Reaction

The government defended the penalty while noting that the Supreme Court has repeatedly narrowed its scope and that research finds no evidence it deters crime better than life imprisonment. Critics said the claim that due legal process fully protects those facing execution is weak. The last hanging in the country took place in 2020 after the Delhi gang‑rape and murder case, yet Parliament has expanded the list of offences punishable by death, a move described as punitive populism aimed at calming public anger over sexual violence.

Context

India’s death‑row population rose to 574 by 31 December 2025, the highest since 2016, driven largely by lower‑court verdicts. A 2015 Law Commission report chaired by Justice A.P. Shah recommended abolishing the death penalty for all crimes except terrorism and war crimes, concluding it fails to achieve any constitutionally valid penal goal.

ExplainerWhy this matters

What Happened

India voted at the UN to reject a global moratorium on the death penalty, saying the decision rests with the nation and that safeguards like the “rarest of rare” standard and a High Court seal are in place.

Why It Matters

The vote highlights a clash between international human‑rights pressure and domestic politics. While the Supreme Court has narrowed death‑penalty use and studies show it does not lower crime rates, the government expands capital‑offence categories, citing public outrage over sexual violence. Critics argue the safeguards do not prevent wrongful convictions and that harsher punishments may even increase violence.

What Happens Next

Human‑rights groups are urging India to impose a formal moratorium and to review laws governing capital punishment. Future parliamentary debates and possible Supreme Court rulings will determine whether the death penalty is retained, narrowed further, or eventually abolished.

Read more at The Hindu - National →