The Daily Pulse

General

Madras High Court Rules Police And Judges Cannot Deny Bail For Bailable Offences

Reported by Faizan Khan (Staff Writer) · The Hindu - National ·

Source: The Hindu
Worth knowing
Madras High Court Rules Police And Judges Cannot Deny Bail For Bailable OffencesPhoto: Wikimedia Commons

Police officers, magistrates, and sessions judges possess no legal discretion to refuse bail when an accused person is booked for bailable offences, the Madras High Court has ruled.

Court Rulings

Justice N. Ramesh expressed shock after a metropolitan magistrate and a sessions judge in Chennai wrongly denied bail in a bailable case. The judge stated that even if an accused cites the wrong legal provision in a bail plea, judicial officers must check whether the actual offences are bailable and decide accordingly under Section 478(1) of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita. The court ordered High Court Registrar General Deepthi Arivunithi to circulate the verdict to all Principal District and Sessions Judges, Chief Judicial Magistrates, and the Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy.

The Case

The ruling came while granting bail to P. Rajagopal from Thiruvanmiyur in Chennai. Chennai Cyber Crime police arrested Rajagopal on October 22, 2026, over an abusive and derogatory remark posted on June 12, 2026, against Chief Minister C. Joseph Vijay on the accused person's X handle. Police booked him under Section 296(b) of the BNSS and Section 67 of the Information Technology Act, 2000, but failed to inform him that both sections were bailable. Because of this, Rajagopal mistakenly filed his bail plea under Section 480 of the BNSS for non-bailable offences. A metropolitan magistrate in Saidapet dismissed his first bail petition on October 27, 2026, citing the grave nature of the offence, pending investigation, and fears of evidence tampering. The Principal Sessions Court in Chennai subsequently dismissed his further bail pleas on November 2 and November 5, 2026.

Legal Conditions

Justice Ramesh clarified that factors like the gravity of an accusation, pending investigation, awaited forensic reports, or fears of absconding serve as grounds for denying bail only in non-bailable cases, not bailable ones. When granting bail for bailable offences, courts may only set bond amounts and decide on sureties without attaching extra conditions. Indigent persons unable to give a bond within a week must be released on their own bond. Bailable bail can only be cancelled by the High Court if the accused acts to prejudice a fair trial, though violation of prior bail bonds in other cases can disqualify someone from bail. Justice Ramesh ordered Rajagopal released immediately upon executing a bond of 25,000 rupees with two sureties of the same amount.

Context

Bailable offences under Indian criminal law are those where granting bail is a matter of right for the accused rather than a matter of judicial discretion. The BNSS and various special criminal laws clearly list which offenses carry bailable status, typically including those with lesser maximum punishments. Judicial oversight exists to protect personal liberty while ensuring that the legal process functions fairly for all citizens.

Read more at The Hindu - National →