The Daily Pulse

General

Top Supreme Court Judge Says Women in High Office Do Not Mean Equal Society

Reported by Kunal Bhatia (Senior Writer) · The Hindu - National ·

Source: The Hindu
Worth knowing
Top Supreme Court Judge Says Women in High Office Do Not Mean Equal SocietyPhoto: Wikimedia Commons

Having a woman in a top public job does not mean equality exists for all women across society, Supreme Court judge Justice B.V. Nagarathna said this week. Speaking at Oxford University's Somerville College on Wednesday, November 18, 2026, she delivered the inaugural Cornelia Sorabji Memorial Lecture. She noted that one woman can reach a senior role while many others still lack access to education, jobs, property, and proper legal help.

Limits of Law

A court ruling alone cannot make every workplace safe, send every girl to school, give every woman her legal share of property, or protect every domestic violence victim on time, the judge stated. Laws also fail if people cannot reach the courts, officials do not act, or social habits stop women from claiming their rights. Constitutional changes giving women one-third of the seats in Parliament and state assemblies show that women need a real part in making decisions, rather than just a basic right to vote. Past exclusion means basic legal equality is not always enough to fix representation.

Structural Barriers

Progress for women cannot be measured just by old unfair rules being cancelled or a few good laws being passed, Justice Nagarathna said. Even though violence against women is now seen as a break of constitutional rights, many victims still fear shame, payback, or money trouble when they go to the police or courts. Women also carry an unfair share of unpaid housework and care duties, which shapes what choices they are able to make in life. True equality must notice that women face very different lives based on caste, class, disability, religion, region, and money.

Context

Justice B.V. Nagarathna is currently among the most senior judges on the Supreme Court of India and is in line to become the country's first female Chief Justice. Her remarks touch on deep-rooted social inequalities that persist despite legal reforms and the rising visibility of individual women in positions of power. Discussions around substantive equality and the burden of unpaid domestic labor remain central to feminist legal theory and human rights advocacy in India.

Read more at The Hindu - National →