The Daily Pulse

Science & Environment

US holds first deep-sea mining auction off American Samoa despite court ruling and local protests

Reported by Harshdeep Singh (Fact-Checker) · The Guardian - Environment ·

Source: The Guardian
Worth knowing
US holds first deep-sea mining auction off American Samoa despite court ruling and local protestsPhoto: Wikimedia Commons

The United States held its first ever deep-sea mining lease sales off the coast of American Samoa on Thursday, moving forward despite an adverse federal court ruling earlier in the week and mounting local opposition. ## The Auction And Sales The live-streamed auction covered 12.7m hectares of seabed marked for mineral exploration. Two areas of the Pacific archipelago were sold for $3m each to Wetstone US Ventures, which was the only bidder according to the Marine Minerals Administration. The buyers now have permission to carry out preliminary activities like bathymetric and geophysical mapping. Miners are searching for metallic nodules touted as a source of rare earths for electric vehicles and renewable energy.

Official Stance And Legal Challenges

Interior secretary Doug Burgum called the sale a historic step for America's energy and mineral security. MMA director Mike Olsen said the action aligns with the administration's agenda to develop offshore critical minerals. However, a federal judge in Hawaii had voided the environmental clearance earlier in the week, ruling that the Endangered Species Act was violated. Earthjustice attorney Chris Eaton stated the auction was unlawful and vowed to push for the leases to be voided. Finafinau founder Sabrina Suluai-Mahuka criticized the sale after the youth nonprofit filed an unsuccessful last-minute petition for an injunction.

Wider Impact And Future Plans

NRDC director Taryn Kiekow Heimer warned the American Samoa sale serves as a template for future applications, noting a second lease sale involving 27.9m hectares of seabed between the Northern Mariana Islands and Guam is tentatively scheduled for 16 December. Guam Senator William Parkinson called on the government to cancel the auctions, stating the Pacific is not for sale. Meanwhile, American Samoa governor Pulaali'i Nikolao Pula and American Samoa Development Council executive director John Wasko expressed support for the economic and scientific opportunities the mining industry could bring.

Context

Deep-sea mining involves exploring the ocean floor for valuable metallic minerals and rare earth elements that are increasingly demanded by modern technology industries. This emerging commercial activity has sparked intense global debate and legal scrutiny regarding potential long-term damage to fragile marine ecosystems and deep-sea biodiversity.

ExplainerWhy this matters

What Happened

The United States government conducted its first commercial deep-sea mining lease auction off the coast of American Samoa, selling two seabed areas to Wetstone US Ventures despite a federal judge ruling that environmental clearances violated the Endangered Species Act.

Why It Matters

This sale represents a major shift toward opening the ocean floor for mineral extraction to supply materials for electric vehicles and renewable energy. Critics and environmental groups warn it sets a dangerous precedent that could permanently damage fragile marine ecosystems before the full environmental consequences are understood.

What Happens Next

Legal battles will continue as environmental groups press courts to nullify the leases, while additional lease sales are tentatively scheduled near Guam and the Northern Mariana Islands in December amid ongoing local resistance.

Read more at The Guardian - Environment →