The Daily Pulse

General

Former CEC S.Y. Quraishi warns that credibility of Election Commission may take decades to repair

Reported by Neha Sharma (Staff Writer) · The Hindu - National ·

Source: The Hindu
Worth knowing
Former CEC S.Y. Quraishi warns that credibility of Election Commission may take decades to repairPhoto: Wikimedia Commons

Former Chief Election Commissioner S.Y. Quraishi warns that India's constitutional bodies need strong safeguards against the misuse of power to protect their standing.

The Election Commission

Speaking in Delhi at the 17th V. M. Tarkunde Memorial Lecture, Mr. Quraishi stated that the Election Commission of India's credibility has been under strain since 2019. He pointed to controversies over the 2024 Lok Sabha election turnout figures, the dissent of former Election Commissioner Ashok Lavasa, and concerns regarding the SIR exercise. Highlighting West Bengal, he noted that out of 27 lakh voters deleted during adjudication, 22 lakh appealed for restoration, but only 1,607 names were restored before the Assembly election because hearings were not completed. He added that appellate tribunal decisions later found 93 percent of more than 1.2 lakh exclusions incorrect. He called for an independent audit of the SIR, transparent appointment processes, and the restoration of unlawfully deleted names.

Judiciary And Legal Concerns

Mr. Quraishi also questioned the 2023 law that replaced the Chief Justice of India with a Union Minister on the selection panel for election commissioners. Regarding the judiciary, he suggested that a panel of three senior judges manage case rosters through a transparent or computerised system to replace the Chief Justice's discretionary power. He noted a backlog of nearly 5.6 crore pending cases across the country and urged time-bound case disposal alongside limits on adjournments. He also criticised inconsistencies in bail decisions, comparing the quick release of a prominent television anchor in November 2020 with the prolonged detention of journalist Siddique Kappan and students jailed for six years without proven charges.

Other Institutions

Turning to the legislature and other bodies, Mr. Quraishi condemned the suspension of 146 MPs in December 2023 during the passage of three major criminal laws. He questioned the impartiality of legislative Speakers in handling disqualification petitions after the 2022 Shiv Sena split in Maharashtra. Furthermore, he cautioned Governors against delaying assent to Bills for political reasons and called for greater scrutiny of the CAG and UPSC appointments.

Context

Constitutional institutions like the Election Commission, judiciary, and audit bodies are designed to act as independent checks on the executive branch of government. Public figures and former officials often use memorial lectures and public addresses to raise concerns about institutional autonomy and procedural fairness in governance.

ExplainerWhy this matters

What Happened

Former Chief Election Commissioner S.Y. Quraishi delivered a lecture warning about declining institutional credibility in India, specifically criticising processes like the SIR exercise, changes to the election commissioner appointment panel, and judicial delays.

Why It Matters

Constitutional bodies such as the Election Commission, the judiciary, and oversight institutions are vital for maintaining a healthy democracy and ensuring free and fair elections. Debates over their independence, appointment procedures, and transparency directly affect public trust in governance and the protection of citizen rights.

What Happens Next

Discussions and legal challenges surrounding the autonomy of constitutional offices, appointment laws, and electoral rolls will likely continue in political and judicial forums.

Read more at The Hindu - National →