Science & Environmentβ’ Updated
COP31 climate summit faces collapse as EU and island nations reject final draft deal
Reported by Arjun Sethi (Fact-Checker) Β· The Guardian - Environment Β·
Confirmed by a second source: BBC News - Science & Environment
UPDATE - follow-up to Cop31 live: EU rejects deal as longest climate summit ever faces collapse: The COP31 climate summit in Antalya faces potential collapse as the European Union and the Republic of the Marshall Islands formally object to the final draft text, while talks extend into a second day of overtime. Ireland's climate minister, Darragh O'Brien, told the plenary that the EU rejects the Antalya pact because it fails to meet the moment and does not even mention fossil fuels. The Marshall Islands also objected, stating the outcome undermines security and fails to provide needed finance while seas rise and people die. China accepted the draft to keep proceedings moving forward, and India spoke on behalf of Like-Minded Developing Countries to say they want to keep working rather than issue a rejection. The UK energy secretary, Miatta Fahnbulleh, criticized the deal as a backward step and the lowest common denominator, noting it misses critical areas like climate finance, emissions reduction in line with 1.5C, transitioning away from fossil fuels, and reducing methane and non-CO2 emissions. Norway also joined the objections, while Ghana criticized the chair's conduct before agreeing to let the text be adopted in the interests of multilateralism.
Reactions
Mohamed Adow, director of Power Shift Africa, criticized the EU's role, stating that adaptation, finance, and the Just Transition mechanism are dead in the water while loss and damage has been erased, amounting to abandonment of vulnerable nations by wealthy countries. A Saudi delegate defended the inclusion of carbon capture and storage, asking how the UN's climate panel can be accused of greenwashing when CCS is recognized as necessary. According to BBC News - Science & Environment, Turkey's environment minister and COP president Murat Kurum expressed hope for a breakthrough, though the EU considers the new text a backward step.
Context
UN climate summits require consensus among participating nations to pass final agreements, meaning a single major bloc or country can block a deal entirely. When negotiations fail to reach an accord, talks are occasionally suspended until future sessions rather than resulting in an adopted treaty. This summit has already surpassed its original Friday deadline, stretching into rare overtime negotiations.
What changed since yesterday
- New Draft Deal Released at COP31 as Talks Stretch Into Final Hours
- Cop31 climate summit enters final hours as third draft text is published in Turkey
- Third Draft Deal Released at COP31 as Overtime Talks Continue in Turkey
- COP31 negotiators face final hours as third draft deal drops amid deep divisions
- COP31 climate summit enters overtime as final draft text draws sharp criticism
- COP31 climate summit stretches into overtime as delegates scrutinize third draft deal
- COP31 negotiators push into overtime as divided climate summit faces possible collapse
- COP31 climate summit enters overtime as ministers debate new draft text
- EU and Panama Reject Draft Pact as COP31 Becomes Longest Climate Summit in History
Latest
COP31 climate summit faces collapse as EU and island nations reject final draft deal
ExplainerWhy this matters
What Happened
Negotiations at the UN COP31 summit in Antalya stalled after a revised draft text omitted direct mentions of transitioning away from fossil fuels and left key finance decisions vague, prompting formal objections from the European Union and the Republic of the Marshall Islands.
Why It Matters
International climate agreements set the baseline targets and financial commitments for global carbon reduction and adaptation efforts. When major blocs like the EU reject a text for lacking ambition, or when island nations state their security is undermined, it highlights a deep rift between wealthy industrial nations, oil-producing states, and climate-vulnerable countries over who bears the cost and responsibility of the green transition.
What Happens Next
If consensus cannot be reached under UN rules, negotiations face suspension until next year, delaying global policy commitments. Co-hosts and delegates must decide whether to continue emergency compromise sessions or allow the current talks to conclude without a comprehensive global deal.
More in Science & Environment
Science & Environmentβ’ UpdatedExplainerVerified β Confirmed by a second source: BBC News - Science & EnvironmentImportant
EU and Panama Reject Draft Pact as COP31 Becomes Longest Climate Summit in History.
Reported by Manish Reddy (Senior Writer) Β· The Guardian - Environment Β·
Science & Environmentβ’ UpdatedExplainerVerified β Confirmed by a second source: BBC News - Science & EnvironmentImportant
COP31 climate summit enters overtime as ministers debate new draft text
Reported by Rohit Yadav (Staff Writer) Β· The Guardian - Environment Β·
Science & Environmentβ’ UpdatedExplainerVerified β Confirmed by a second source: BBC News - Science & EnvironmentImportant
COP31 negotiators push into overtime as divided climate summit faces possible collapse
Reported by Manish Reddy (Senior Writer) Β· The Guardian - Environment Β·
